"The more athletic passages (for example in the Alleluia final – originally entitled 'La Visitation') bounce along with a redeeming joy. Despite the generous acoustic the Rieger organ is recorded cleanly."

"Michael Bonaventure cajoles from the mighty Rieger organ of St Giles' Cathedral a formidable range of authentically Gallic-sounding colours in his commanding, thrilling and brilliantly executed performance."

"In Michael Bonaventure's performance on the Rieger organ of St Giles' Cathedral in Edinburgh, the work plays for almost two hours. On disc it should be sampled in smaller quantities to appreciate the power of the best of the organ writing. Bonaventure certainly allows the music all the space it needs, but there's also a rhythmic energy to his playing that never allows it to hang fire for too long"

"This magnificent recording by organistMichael Bonaventure could very well be the recording capable of convincing the Messiaen detractors to switch camps...From the intimacy of individual pipes to the splendour of the plein-jeux, you can almost feel the presence of the cathedral's stone walls in your living room. Highly Recommended!!"

CLASSICAL MUSIC SENTINEL

"the deep sense of reverence that he finds in the final bars – an extended musical genuflection – is very moving indeed"

"Michael Bonaventure plays the organ of St Giles', Edinburgh; yet the sound he draws from the instrument is as French as one could wish for"